15 Best Eggs Benedict in Sarasota [2022]

11 mins read

This is a list of the best Eggs Benedicts Sarasota has to offer.

Everyone knows the key to a good eggs benny is the hollandaise sauce.

There’s a fine line between a runny and coagulated consistency.

Max's Table Eggs Benedict

These are the places that got it right! Perfect poached eggs and rich hollandaise sauce.

  1. Lovely Square
  2. Station 400
  3. Max’s Table
  4. Sun Garden Cafe
  5. Original Word of Mouth
  6. The Breakfast Company
  7. MADE Restaurant
  8. Millie’s
  9. Toasted Mango
  10. Sunnyside
  11. Breakfast at Victoria’s
  12. Eggstraordinary Cafe
  13. Another Broken Egg Cafe
  14. Keke’s
  15. Metro Diner
Lovely Square Sarasota

Lovely Square

6559 Gateway Ave, Sarasota, FL

Lovely Square is a small eclectic breakfast eatery in Gulf Gate. You would never know it from the outside, but this cafe has delicious food and a homey charm. Our favorite menu items were the traditional eggs benedict and the shrimp avocado eggs benedict.

Once you get past the artful presentation, you’ll be awed by the richness of the hollandaise sauce. The diced potatoes are legendary.

Classic Eggs Benedict

Perfectly poached cage free eggs on an English muffin with Canadian bacon and rich hollandaise sauce.

Shrimp and Avocado Benedict

Cage free eggs on top of an English muffin with shrimp and avocado. Topped with flavorful hollandaise sauce.

Station 400

400 N Lemon Ave, Sarasota, FL

Station 400 Eggs Benedict

Station 400 has the best brunch in Sarasota. They also happen to have the best eggs Benedict in downtown! Imagine perfectly poached eggs with flavorful hollandaise sauce. Sit in their covered back patio and try their excellent mimosas.

Truffle Eggs Benedict

Perfectly poached eggs over an English muffin with arugula, Canadian bacon, roasted mushrooms and truffled flavored hollandaise.

Fried Green Tomato Benedict

Toasted English muffin with poached eggs, crispy bacon, arugula and pesto hollandaise sauce.

Max's Table Eggs Benedict

Max’s Table

115 S Tamiami Trail, Osprey, FL

Max’s Table has a cult following of eggs Benedict lovers. They have a cozy inside seating area with a modern atmosphere. This is one of those great breakfast places you’ll keep coming back to. It’s usually busy, so expect it to be fairly loud.

Traditional Eggs Benedict

Homemade hollandaise sauce over their famous poached eggs with fresh Canadian bacon and a side of delicious potatoes.

Salmon Eggs Benedict

Smoked Salmon (cold) on a toasted English muffin with homemade hollandaise sauce and poached eggs. Omg!

Sun Garden Cafe

210 Avenida Madera, Sarasota, FL

Sun Garde Cafe Sarasota

The most ordered Sun Garden Cafe menu items are the egg Benedicts. Their eggs benny are unique, fresh and flavorful. They have a beautiful covered outdoor patio. Which will make you feel like you’re in some outdoor restaurant in Europe.

Cajun Benedict

Their Cajun eggs Benedict comes with 2 poaches eggs, blackened mahi-mahi, crawfish, Gulf of Mexico shrimp and mouth watering hollandaise sauce.

Shrimp Benedict

Poached eggs over Gulf shrimp with spinach and hollandaise sauce. The fresh shrimp is amazing!

Sun Garden Cafe Eggs Benedict

Get a side of Sun Garden Cafe’s famous sweet potato pancakes, avocado toast and mimosas! While it is a drive to Siesta Key, it’s completely worth it.

Original Word of Mouth

6604 Gateway Ave, Sarasota, FL

If you’re looking for the best eggs Benedict, just ask the locals. They’ll all tell you to try Original Word of Mouth. The eggs benny is their most popular dish and many swear it’s their favorite one.

The food and service is impeccable. They have a comfortable, inviting and friendly atmosphere.

Classic Eggs Benedict

Shaved grilled ham with perfectly poached eggs and their signature hollandaise sauce. On top of a toasted English muffin.

Country Benedict

Grilled Tennessee mountain biscuit with a sausage patty, two eggs and homemade sausage gravy.

The Breakfast Company

7246 55th Ave E, Bradenton, FL

The Breakfast Company has a loyal following and has some of the best breakfast in Sarasota. They put a creative twist on the eggs Benedict. Ask the locals or check their reviews, everyone is happy with their eggs benny.

Short Rib Eggs Benedict

Four hour tender braised short rib over an English muffin with mouth watering hollandaise sauce.

Twisted Eggs Benedict

Applewood smoked bacon, hashbrown waffle and chipotle hollandaise sauce.

Cali Vegan Eggs Benedict

Sliced avocado, tomato and Just Egg vegan eggs.

MADE Restaurant

1990 Main St #112, Sarasota, FL

MADE Restaurant has the best brunch in town and is one of the best restaurants in downtown Sarasota! They specialize in modern American comfort food and have Instagram-friendly food presentation.

They use locally sourced ingredients from many Sarasota and Florida farms. It’s usually very busy, so expect a wait and some noise. Free parking is in the garage behind the restaurants and reservations are highly recommended.

Brisket Eggs Benedict

Super tender slow roasted brisket with billionaire bacon, pepper milk sausage gravy, jalapeno jack cheese. Made the perfect poached eggs and chipotle hollandaise sauce on top!

Pork on Pork on Pork Benedict

Smoked roasted pork shoulder with billionaire bacon, pepper milk sausage gravy and chipotle hollandaise sauce. With perfectly poached eggs.


3900 Clark Rd, Sarasota, FL

Millie’s has a comfortable atmosphere with a “grandma’s house” feel to it. They have very good food and great service! People love their eggs Benedicts, grits, biscuits and gravy. They have a delicious traditional eggs Benedict and they’re happy to customize it.

Toasted Mango

430 N Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL

Toasted Mango is a small breakfast joint with a very attentive wait staff. The waitresses are polite, always paying attention and really care about your experience. Considering it’s one of the most popular breakfast spots in Sarasota, they’re really good about handling everything.

Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict

Great poached eggs with smoked salmon with hollandaise sauce and home fries.

Sunnyside Cafe

4900 N Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL

Sunnyside Cafe Sarasota

Sunnyside Cafe is a cute hole in the wall with extremely slow service. While their eggs Benedict’s are great, but the service needs some work. We highly recommend you look at their menu before and order right away.

However, they poach their eggs right and their hollandaise sauce is excellent, so 100% worth the visit.

The Sunnyside Eggs Benedict

Two mouth watering poached eggs with home cured Salmon on a toasted English muffin. We loved their their homemade hollandaise sauce.

Breakfast at Victoria’s

4141 S Tamiami Trail Unit 10, Sarasota, FL

Breakfast at Victoria’s is a great place to eat in the morning. It’s family owned, trendy and has a very friendly atmosphere. They have excellent eggs Benedicts with cream cheese. Yum! They know how to poach an egg perfectly.

Prosciutto Benedict

English muffin with crispy prosciutto and brie cheese. Covered with perfect poached eggs and hollandaise sauce.

Salmon Eggs Benedict

English muffin with smoked salmon, cream cheese and hollandaise sauce. With poached eggs of course.

Eggstraordinary Cafe

3981 Cattlemen Rd, Sarasota, FL

Eggstraordinary Cafe serves many different kinds of eggs benny. This is a traditional breakfast place you find down the street. We loved their Lox eggs Benedict and Florentine benny.

Another Broken Egg Cafe

140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL

Another Broken Egg Cafe is one of the most popular breakfast restaurants on Siesta Key. They make the best crab eggs Benedict and lobster eggs Benedict in Sarasota! Make sure to try their spicy Bloody Mary and New Orleans style beignets. Their eggs benny with crab cakes is a must!

Crab Cake Eggs Benedict

Crab cakes on an english muffin with poached eggs and andouille-infused hollandaise sauce. Topped with red peppers and green onions.

Blackstone Benedict

Grilled red tomato on an English muffin with poached eggs and their signature hollandaise sauce. Along with chopped bacon and green onions.

Keke’s Sarasota

3456 Clark Rd, Sarasota, FL

Keke’s has many locations. They’ve mastered making poached eggs and serve amazing eggs Benedict. They are a chain but they’re great at what they do.

They offer a traditional eggs Benedict, Eggs Florentine and Eggs Portabella. If you’re looking for restaurants that serve eggs Benedict, give them a try.

Metro Diner

6056 N Lockwood Ridge Rd, Sarasota, FL

Metro Diner is a breakfast chain based in Tampa, Florida with over 58 locations nationwide. They’re known for their amazing food and excellent service. Locals love their chicken and waffles, chicken pot pie and fried chicken eggs Benedicts. It’s also a great place for mimosas and Bloody Mary’s.

Fried Chicken Eggs Benedict

Buttermilk marinated chicken tenders with poached eggs on a fresh biscuit. Topped with their signature creamy Hollandaise sauce.

Best Eggs Benedict (Sarasota)

We created a map of the best eggs benedict Sarasota has to offer near your location.

Eggs Benedict Places [Bonus]

Here are some more places that have great eggs benedict.

  1. First Watch
  2. Shore St. Armands
  3. Pier 22
  4. Clasico Italian Chophouse
  5. Yoder’s Restaurant